Latest articles on Life Insurance, Non-life Insurance, Mutual Funds, Bonds, Small Saving Schemes and Personal Finance to help you make well-informed money decisions.
The post COVID-19 world will not be the same. Many theories and practices are getting challenged. New strategies are being promoted and old ones that were sidelined are gaining ground.
COVID-19 began as a health scare, but its biggest impact has been on the economy and on people’s incomes. Governments, worried about the economy, unemployment and loss of income, have announced large increases in spending.
Taking debt to revive the economy
All this, of course, costs money. This money spent by the government will need to be borrowed. The borrowing will increase the debt burden of the government. It may lead to an increase in interest rates. The extra spending may lead to inflation over time.
An MMT supporter will say that’s perfect. Save the economy, boost the employment. Go ahead and spend the money. The central bank will print the money and will fund the increase in government spending. Interest rates thus won’t rise. We will worry about deficits and inflation later.
Modern Monetary Theory rests on a few broad principles, as I understand it.
-Economies should aim at full employment at all times and, fiscal policy, more than monetary policy, should be the main tool to achieve that objective.
-The government does that by investing in infrastructure, spending on the environment or by guaranteeing a job to everyone.
-Deficits matter but do not worry about them (deficit is the government expenditure over its revenue)
-A country which can print and spend its own currency need not worry about debt and deficits.
-The increase in deficit can be financed by the central bank directly (monetization) and thus will not cause an increase in market interest rates
There is indeed some merit in these principles.
The experience with developed countries
The Central Banks of developed countries have been following the mandate of full employment with controlled inflation for decades. MMT shifts that responsibility on to the governments. MMT also treats the central bank as part of the government. So a bond issued by the government to fund its spending from its left pocket is being financed by the central bank which is its own right pocket.
As we have seen over the last decade, large central banks have undertaken Quantitative Easing (QE – money printing to buy financial assets), which has led to an increase in asset prices. At the same time, governments across the world cut back their spending and reduced their fiscal deficit (austerity).
The net result has been that most economies, despite their central banks being on steroids, never saw any sustained improvement in growth, employment and incomes, but have seen their stock markets at record highs.
Imagine, if the governments had instead taken the money printed by the central banks and spent on the ‘real economy’ – by creating more physical infrastructure, cleaning up the environment, providing a job guarantee to everyone, spending more on health and education.
That sounds appealing, doesn’t it? Politicians all over the world should love MMT theorists. Politicians can promise employment, healthcare, education, roads, and bridges without worrying about how to fund them.
But as Yogi Berra, the American Baseball legend once said, “In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice, But in Practice, there is.”
Theoretically, the government is supposed to spend and at the same time use tax increases as a way of ensuring that the spending does not become inflationary. But in practice, it may be difficult to raise taxes or cut back on spending, which may create unemployment.
Post the COVID pandemic, not only in theory, but also in practice, we are seeing large-scale monetization of government’s deficits. So, although MMT may not be the official policy of any government, but certain facets of it is already under use.
MMT and investments
MMT will have implications on how you invest, where you invest and what returns you should expect.
-The immediate impact it seems to have is on fixed-income investments.
-Large-scale bond buying by central banks will lead to global bond yields trading at lower levels
-We are seeing this across the world and to an extent in India as well, with the RBI beginning to finance the increase in fiscal deficit
-The role of the central bank diminishes and the governments may keep interest rates lower than warranted.
-Equities may get a boost
-The increased spending, if channeled to better health and education, cleaner environment and increased physical infrastructure, will boost growth
-Corporates can benefit from the increased spending and from the higher incomes out of full employment.
-Real Assets such as real estate, infrastructure will benefit from the increased government spending
-Higher inflation should make gold attractive an attractive proposition
-Unlike currencies, gold cannot be inflated or printed; it is thus less susceptible to government manipulation and the effects of MMT.
-Gold has historically retained a relatively stable purchasing power, whereas practically all currencies have lost purchasing power in the long run
-Gold thus acts as a hedge in times of high inflation, which pushes gold prices higher in inflationary
periods
So if practice is not as per theory, which is to be expected, gold is the asset to own. At Quantum, we have always advocated gold as your hedge against foolish actions of politicians and central bankers. MMT or not, that doesn’t change, does it?
The acceptance of MMT is growing. Japan has followed a version of it for decades. Few more countries may follow.
For India or for that matter any other emerging market, which depends on foreign capital for its growth, we don’t see MMT becoming a reality anytime soon.
You expressly agree the use of the service is at your sole risk. The service is provided on an "as is" and "as available" basis. www.surojitkala.com expressly disclams all warranties of any kind, whether express or implied, including, but not limited to the implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose and non-infringement. www.surojitkala.com makes no warranty the services will meet your requirements, or the services will be uninterrupted, timely, secure, or error free. Nor does www.surojitkala.com make any warranty as to the results that may be obtained through the service or that defects in the software will be corrected. You understand and agree any material and/ or data downloaded or otherwise obtained through the use of the service is done at your own discretion and risk and you will be solely responsible for any damage to your computer systems or loss of data that results from the download of such material and/ or data. www.surojitkala.com makes no warranty regarding any goods or services purchased or obtained through the service or any transactions entered into through the service. No advice or information, whether oral or written, which you obtain from www.surojitkala.com or through the service shall create any warranty not expressly made herein.
You acknowledge that www.surojitkala.com site may contain links to other web sites operated by third parties ("linked sites"). You acknowledge that, when you click on a link to visit a linked site, a frame may appear that contains the www.surojitkala.com logo, advertisements and/ or other content selected by www.surojitkala.com. You acknowledge that www.surojitkala.com and its sponsors neither endorse nor are affiliated with the linked site or any link contained in a link site, or any changes or updates to such sites. You also acknowledge that www.surojitkala.com is providing these links to you only as a convenience.
www.surojitkala.com does not endorse in anyway any advertisers/ contents of advertisers on its webpages. Please therefore verify the veracity of all information on your own before undertaking reliance and actioning thereupon. www.ecrwealth.com shall not be responsible nor liable for any consequential damages arising on account of your relying on the contents of the advertisement.
This site is the responsibility of www.surojitkala.com
We want you to
What Information is, or may be, collected from you?
We will collect certain anonymous information in standard usage logs through our Web server, including: computer-identification information obtained from "cookies," sent to your browser from a
We may collect the following personally identifiable information about you:
Who collects the information?
We will collect anonymous traffic information from you when you visit our site
We will collect personally identifiable information about you only as part of a voluntary registration process.
Our advertisers may collect anonymous traffic information from their own assigned cookies to your browser
The Site contains links to other Web sites. We are not responsible for the privacy practices of such Web sites
We offer a collection of online services which are available to you. Please understand that any information that is disclosed in these areas becomes public information. We have no control over its use and you should exercise caution when disclosing your personal information to anyone.
How's the information used?
We use personal information to:
We use contact information internally to:
Generally, we use anonymous traffic information to:
With whom will your information be shared?
We will not disclose any of your personally identifiable information to third parties unless:
We will not use your financial information for any purpose other than to provide services to you.
What choices are available to you regarding collection, use and distribution of your information?
Supplying personally identifiable information is entirely voluntary. You are not required to register with us in order to use our site. However, we offer some services only to visitors who do register.
Upon request, we will remove your personally identifiable information from our database, thereby canceling your registration.
If we plan to use your personally identifiable information for any commercial purposes, we will notify you at the time we collect that information and allow you to opt-out of having your information used for those purposes.
All sites that are customizable require that you accept cookies. You also must accept cookies to register as someone for access to some of our services. e.g Online Portfolio. For information on how to set your browser to alert you to cookies, or to reject cookies, go to http://www.cookiecentral.com/faq/.
What security procedures are in place to protect information from loss, misuse or alteration?
To protect against the loss, misuse and alteration of the information under our control, we have in place appropriate physical, electronic and managerial procedures. For example, our servers are accessible only to authorized personnel.
Although we will endeavor to safeguard the confidentiality of your personally identifiable information, transmissions made by means of the Internet cannot be made absolutely secure. By using this site, you agree that we will have no liability for disclosure of your information due to errors in transmission or unauthorized acts of third parties.
Policy Updates
We reserve the right to change or update these policies at any time upon reasonable notice, effective immediately upon posting to this site.